Asana vs Mattermost

Asana and Mattermost (Mattermost is a secure collaboration platform for connecting your teams, tools and processes to accelerate mission-critical work.) both appear on the Smoower Developer Ecosystem Index.

Mattermost (rank #38) holds a modest lead over Asana (rank #338) on the overall Smoower ecosystem score (62 vs 43). The gap of 19 points reflects composite signals across code, docs, community and reach.

On code quality (the state of repositories, tests, releases and polish), Mattermost is clearly ahead of Asana. On education (docs, guides and learning material for developers), Asana is slightly ahead of Mattermost. On community (issue response, PR reviews and discussion health), Mattermost is ahead of Asana. On reach (how visible the ecosystem is beyond its own repos), Mattermost is clearly ahead of Asana. On momentum (release cadence and how fast the ecosystem moves), Mattermost is clearly ahead of Asana.

Asana carries 1,843 GitHub stars across 34 public repos, with 8 repositories active in the last 90 days and 2 external contributors on record. Mattermost shows 49,882 stars across 262 public repos, 58 active in the last 90 days and 105 external contributors. The star gap on its own does not decide the comparison, but Mattermost's footprint is roughly 27.1x larger, which usually shows up in downstream signals like inbound issues and third party integrations.

Asana is the stronger read for anyone weighting education. Mattermost looks better where momentum is the deciding factor. The table below breaks the scores down pillar by pillar; the linked profiles cover the underlying repos, docs and community signals in full.